Reviewed - 11th July 2002 by SBG

Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (2000) - Columbia / TriStar

Director :Ang Lee

Starring : Chow Yun-Fat, Michelle Yeoh, Zhang Ziyi, Chen Chang, Sihung Lung, Pei-pei Cheng, Fazeng Li and Li Li.

Picture 2.35:1 Anamorphic, DTS and DD 5.1 Mandarin, DD 5.1 English-Dubbed, Dual-Layer, Keep Case

Running Time : 119 mins

The story:

Hide your strength from others.

Two master warriors (Chow Yun Fat and Michelle Yeoh) are faced with their greatest challenge when the treasured Green Destiny sword is stolen by a young aristocrat named Jen (Zhang Ziyi). Jen should be preparing for an arranged marriage, but the like of a warrior seems more appealing as she reveals her superior fighting talents with the aid of the sword. As each warrior battles for justice, they come face to face with their worst enemy - and the inescapable, enduring power of love.

The summary:

I'm pretty sure that most of you are aware of "Crouching Tiger", winner of two Golden Globes, four BAFTAs and four Academy Awards. If you're not, let me enlighten you. Crouching Tiger is the martial-arts English subtitled, Mandarin-language film that took the world by storm a couple of years back, mainly due to the involvement of action choreographer Woo-ping Yuen (who was also responsible for the fighting sequences in "The Matrix"). Although I don't have a problem with subtitled films, I was pleased to find the inclusion of an English-dubbed soundtrack, something that is lacking from the region one release.

So as you may have gathered by now, as with "The Matrix" special effects and stunts are the order of the day. Woo-ping Yuen takes the fight sequences in Crouching Tiger to another level, by giving the warriors the power to defy gravity and battle it out with swords whilst skipping across roofs and trees. Whilst visually, this may look amazing, it does make the film a little too "fantastical" for my liking. It may be a landmark in choreographed fight-sequences, but don't let this gloss over some major flaws with the film. For starters it's just not realistic. Even though the warriors can kind of fly, they don't "fly" in a realistic manner, rather in jumping around attached to wire kind of way. The scenes where they're standing perched on those trees is probably the best example of this but on many of the scenes it's just looks a bit daft. The real problem though is the lack of depth to the main characters. We don't really get to find out much about them, nor do they seem to interact properly with each other. There's no chemistry between Master Li Mu Bai and Yu Shu Lien (Yun-Fat and Yeoh) which makes you wonder why the Yoda-like Li Mu Bia would bother persistently trying to take her under his wing when she clearly doesn't want his help. The same can be said of the rather shallow "romance" thread in which we see little love between them.

On the plus side, as I mentioned before it really is stunning to watch. Some of the effects and choreography (all of which are fight sequences) will really blow you away. The speed of the swordfights are amazing and are presented as almost ballet-like dance sequences. Much to my surprise, I also found it quite funny at times. The best example of the humour is the fight scene in the restaurant where Yu Shu Lien takes on everybody in the house! The story beautifully unravels and as you'd expect from a Chinese film, it has a moral to be learned from it. It's no surprise that Crouching Tiger managed to break through to the mainstream Western market, so sit back, enjoy some culture and forgive it's misgivings and you'll be in for a treat.

The standard version of Crouching Tiger has been available for some time, so is there really any reason to buy this more expensive Superbit release? Well that depends what you're looking for in a DVD. If you love all the bonus material and extras that go with the package then you'll be disappointed to find there's no extras whatsoever on this disc. But for pure film-lovers who just want the best possible version of the film, then the high definition Superbit transfer (which uses a high bit rate digital transfer process, hence the lack of space for extras) is the one to go for. It looks fantastic and we really cant find fault with the picture. There's also a DTS 5.1 soundtrack, although it's Mandarin only so you'll have to make do with DD 5.1 if you want to listen in English.

 

Extras:

None

 


Our Verdict...


Martial arts epic full of fantastic fight sequences. Visually stunning but the depth of the story is questionable. A case of style over content. 7/10

An impressive picture as you'd expect but compared to the standard release there's little noticeable improvement. The resolution is better so if you own a large widescreen TV or projector you'll benefit more from Superbit. 9.5/10



Three soundtracks available (Mandarin DTS and DD5.1 and English-dubbed 5.1) but with very little difference between them it comes down to personal preference. They're well balanced and the musical score comes across well. Particularly impressive during the fight sequences. 7/10



The extras are sacrificed for the enhanced (Superbit) video image. In other words there's none.. 0/10




66%