Reviewed - 21st February 2001 by SBG

Braveheart (1995) - 20th Century Fox

Director : Mel Gibson

Starring : Mel Gibson, Sophie Marceau, Patrick McGoohan, Catherine McCormack.

Picture 2.35:1 Anamorphic, DD 5.1, Dual-Layer 2-Disc, Keep Case

Running Time : 171 mins

The story:

Life without freedom is no life at all.

The story of William Wallace (Mel Gibson), a 13th century farmer who emerged as Scotland's leader in its fight for independence from the enforced English rule of Edward Longshanks (Patrick McGoohan). Wallace had seen the English brutality firsthand as they took away everything that he loved. But following the murder of his young bride of 1-day, he feels enough is enough and begins his journey that leads him to become the hero of the Scottish rebellion. And straight into battle with the English army..


The summary:

This epic saga has been a while coming to DVD and for good reason - famed for the gloriously choreographed battle scenes throughout it's three hours, the already memorable scenes were given a facelift in the form of a digital remastering. That's not to say it looked shoddy beforehand, but the studio's realise that they have to go one step further to make the DVD edition something special. Was it worth the effort? Well although some may disagree, I firmly believe they are the minority and the rest, like me, will relish the opportunity to own this historic masterpiece.

This is the story of a hero, William Wallace. Perhaps he wont start out as one in your mind, but believe me - by the end of the film you'll believe you have just watched the story of a legend! Brutally graphic throughout, the battle scenes are some of the most amazing every staged on film. The realism is incredible and perhaps, from time to time, it does all get a little too violent, but hey - that's what great battles were like and Gibson makes no effort to back away from the powerful and moving images of war. As well as directing and producing Braveheart, Gibson also plays a magnificent hero and likewise Patrick McGoohan revels in his role as the evil-minded Edward I. In between the battles things can slow at times, but never to the point of distracting from the story and things soon begin to break into a gallop as the next conflict commences. Some doubts have also been raised as to how factual Braveheart actually is, and it's obviously been given some of the box-office gloss but I dont believe the basic story has been lost amongst all this.

This audio and video on this DVD version is without a doubt the best version to date, especially given the remastering. The video is near perfect and the soundtrack is a very good 5.1 mix that's possibly just a little too soft in places. What does come as a bit of a surprise though, is the apparent lack of supplementary material on this Special Edition. Despite the inclusion of a second disc, it seems devoid of anything bar a sub-30 minute documentary! OK, the film is nigh on 3 hours, but either leave off the documentary or include something else with it! It hardly seems worth the effort of swapping discs..

Extras:

* Audio Commentary - No prizes for guessing the only voice on the commentary track - it's the Actor/Producer/Director himself, Mel Gibson. Obviously entitled to feel proud of himself, Mel goes to great lengths to explain the work that went on behind the scenes and the efforts made to make the wonderful battle scenes. The only trouble is, Mel's monotone voice begins to tire after a while and it all becomes rather dull. Perhaps the Shelia's will find this more appealing..

* Original Theatrical Trailer

Disc Two:

* Documentary - 'Braveheart: A Filmmaker's Passion'. Surprisingly the only thing on disc 2 is this much shorter than anticipated behind-the-scenes documentary. It's well made and looks good but considering it's 28 mins run-time contains far too many scenes from the film and not enough from behind. Could have been so much better. If you're left wondering what the rest of the disc was used for you can amuse yourself by re-watching this and changing the audio to Czech, Danish, Finnish, Polish etc etc etc..


Our Verdict...


An epic of Gladiator proportions, this may not be to everyone's taste, but you simply have to watch it once to find out for yourself. 9/10



Fresh from being digitally remastered this is every bit as good as the original cinema release. Colours are not as vibrant as they could be, but they are as Gibson intended and the clarity is simply superb. 9/10



Skip from battle to battle to witness the 5.1 mix in all its glory, this is a fine blend of action and the excellent James Horner musical score. 8/10



This special 2-disc edition will make your mouth water - until you actually take a look at the extras.. The SE refers to the digitally remastered film and not bonus material. There's a commentary track and trailer on the first disc and nothing other than a half hour documentary on the 2nd! 5/10




85%

Buy Now! BlackStar.co.uk - The UK's Biggest Video Store