Reviewed - 21st February 2000 by SBG

As Good As It Gets (1997) - Columbia Tristar

Director :James L. Brooks

Starring : Jack Nicholson, Helen Hunt, Greg Kinnear, Cuba Gooding Jr

Picture 1.85:1 Anamorphic, DD 5.1, Single-Layer, Keep Case

Running Time : 133mins

The story:

Brace yourself for Melvin!

A romantic comedy-drama in which Melvin Udall (Nicholson) is an obsessive, compulsive novelist who takes pride in his ability to affront, repulse and offend. He hates people, he hates animals and his insensitive actions make him no friends. So when his gay neighbour Simon (Kinnear) is hospitalised he is horrified at being bullied into helping him out by looking after his dog. It is during this enforced 'act of kindness' that he befriends Carol (Hunt) - a waitress at his local restaurant. As he is forced into thinking about his actions, his unlikely relationship with Simon and Carol help bring him back into the human race.

A refreshing change from the usual blend of current Hollywood romances, As Good As It Gets is not a film for people that take life too seriously. Have a laugh at the ignorance of people and enjoy it for the comedy that it is.


The summary:

An extremely well written film with a fine performance from Nicholson in particular, that earned him an Oscar. It's difficult to see how anyone else could have played the part of Melvin. Foul-mouthed and abusive to the extreme, he still somehow endears himself to the watching audience. You'll laugh at his cruelness, his quirky rituals and the misfortunes of the people he encounters. It's a comedy without the jokes. It's funny because it's an ordinary person living his ordinary life. No action or special effects required thank you very much.. this is an Academy Award winning film about human nature. Perhaps the only question mark hanging over an otherwise faultless film - and I am trying to find niggles here - is the romantic element. In a film about everyday people, does this kind of thing happen? Only to film stars..

A nice disc from Columbia TriStar with a superb transfer but lacking in the supplemental department. This might have something to do with the vast selection of foreign soundtracks and subtitles taking up all the space! Still, if you're only going to pick one extra to accompany the film it's the audio commentary. A must-buy.

 

Extras:

* Directors Commentary - Engrossing commentary. With appearances from the cast too.

* Theatrical Trailer - A trailer!

* Filmographies - Career synopsis of Director and cast.

 


Our Verdict...


Hugely enjoyable. It's one you'll watch again and again - 9/10



Non-grainy and colourful throughout, but not on par with the top discs. 8/10



Very little in the way of effects, but a good DD 5.1 balance. 8/10



It's good to see the inclusion of a Directors commentary on a region 2 disc. 6/10




85%

Buy Now! BlackStar.co.uk - The UK's Biggest Video Store