Reviewed - 22nd February 2001 by PCL

Apt Pupil (1998) - Columbia/Tristar

Director : Bryan Singer

Starring : Ian Mckellen, Brad Renfro, Bruce Davidson, Elias Koteas & David Schwimmer

Picture 2.35:1 & 4:3 Fullscreen, DD 5.1, Dual-Sided, Dual Layer, Keep Case

Running Time : 112 mins

The story:

If you don't believe in the existence of evil you've got a lot to learn.

Neighborhood boy Todd Bowden (Renfro) discovers that an old man living on his block named Arthur Denker (Mackellan) is a nazi war criminal. Bowden confronts Denker and offers him a deal: Bowden will not go to the authorities if Denker tells him stories of the concentration camps in WWII. Denker agrees and Bowden starts visiting him regularly. The more stories Bowden hears, the more it affects his personality and his relationship with his parents and those around him.


The summary:

Adapted from a novella by Stephen King, Apt Pupil takes a dark journey into the hearts of men that propagate Evil. We meet schoolboy Todd Bowden (Renfro) who is studying the atrocities of the holocaust and the nazi's. He is an average student with more than a passing interest in the evil that men do. Little by little he realizes that one of his neighbours is a wanted Nazi war criminal called Kurt Dussander (McKellan) and he blackmails him to tell him the gruesome details of the killings in exchange for his silence. Dussander is reluctant at first but for a man that spent so much of his life performing genocide he slowly begins to enjoy his retelling of the War and it begins to spark feelings long since buried deep inside him.

Ian McKellen is a revelation as Dussander. The darkness he breathes into the character is amazing and at times, despite his frailty he does seem genuinely scary. I would liken the part (although to a lesser extent) to that of Hannibal Lecter, also portrayed by another of Britain's finest actors. The film is really a moral piece about the Evil that some people have inside and how given the right circumstances it can be a guiding influence and infiltrate their way of thinking. Bowden learns a lot from Dussander and slowly sinks into his own depravity, although heavily desensitized from the King Novella. Renfro plays this a lot louder than McKellen who is more scheming and masterful. Ultimately Renfro is acted off the screen and in some scenes is actually made to look too contrived. Also watch out for the incredibly campy and pretty dire performance of David Schwimmer, who looks majorly out of his depth. Overall this is a chilling thriller along the lines of Misery and will keep you entertained with its psychological twists and turns.

The DVD release is a sturdy package with good all round sound and picture. It is only let down heavily by the extra's which are almost non existent and do not compliment the film at all.

Extras:

* Theatrical Trailer

* Bio's & Filmographies - A text based affair that features only four bio's. very lacking in detail.

* Making of Featurette - A six and a half minute extended trailer for the film interspersed with interviews with the major cast and crew.

 


Our Verdict...


Adapted from a Stephen King novella this is journey into Evil. Great performance from McKellan makes this a chilling thriller. 7.5/10



Crisp and detailed but with slight grain throughout. Not one of the best pictures we have seen but still adds depth to the film. Dark scenes are impressive and colours are lightly subdued. 7
/10



The 5.1 is used rather timidly throughout the film. It is rarely used to full effect except for a few key scenes. Very average but also adds well to the suspense. 6.5/10



A major let down with only a trailer and a short featurette to speak of. Well below par for Columbia. 2/10




68%