Reviewed - 13th March 2000 by PCL

American History X (1999) - New Line

Director : Tony Kaye

Starring : Edward Norton, Edward Furlong, Stacey Keach, Beverley D'Angelo, Fairuza Balk & Elliot Gould.

Picture 1.85:1, DD 5.1, Dual-Layer, Snap Case

Running Time : 119 mins

The story:

United by hate, divided by truth.

Haunted by memories of his murdered father Derek Vinyard (Edward Norton) is the charismatic young leader of a group of white Nazi worshipping, supremacists intent on bringing freedom to the hard working, patriotic, white men of America. One night his younger brother, Danny (Edward Furlong - Terminator 2) Catches three black youth's trying to steal Derek's car. Fuelled by hate and anger Derek kills two of the boys and is promptly caught and jailed for murder. Derek learns the hard way that life in prison is a whole new world and must adjust both his views and his attitude in order to survive. On the outside Danny tries hard to follow in Derek's footsteps, slowly, but surely filling himself with the same prejudices and hatred and entwining his life in that of the guru of the nazi supremacists (Stacey Keach). Once Derek is released he realises that he must confront his old ways in a bid to better himself and save his brother from making the same mistakes.

The summary:

To say this film is about racism and bigotry is to do it a great injustice. Its more than that in a superb multi faceted way. Its so brilliantly captures Derek Vinyard's struggle to come to terms with his father's premature death by allowing his hatred and blame to influence his racist teachings. Used as a puppet for the maniacally militant Cameron and his group of modern day nazi's, Derek believes so vehemotely in what he is trying to achieve. But what seems so very clear at the beginning begins to fray at the edges until Derek sees that what he is doing is ultimately wrong and really does not make his life any better. It is this capacity for good and faith in what he can do to make his family's life better that lifts this film up and makes you listen. Derek's real quest is not to rid his neighbourhood of "the enemy" but to redeem himself by saving his brother from going down the same tired road that he did.

As a well written and well executed piece of film making this is one of the best drama's that I have encountered in a long while. Factor in the superb acting of Edward Norton and you have a serious contender for one of the best films of the nineties. This is a must for any collection.

Extras:

* Deleted Scenes - 3 Deleted scenes. One of which should definitely have been in the film.

* Theatrical trailer

* Cast and Crew biographies - Quite well informed.

 


Our Verdict...


An absolute modern classic, Kaye's direction and Norton's acting steal the show. You WILL want to see this again and again. 10/10



Good colour and brightness add a summer feel to Venice beach. Almost no artifacts and grain free. Black and white sections are crisp and detailed. 9/10



Great dialogue separation and a few good surround effects. Occasional moments of good bass extensions but this film does not rely too heavily on its Dolby Digital soundtrack. 7/10



Very few extra's, Especially for a New Line release (Why no platinum edition?) Great deleted scenes but could definately have benefited from a making of documentary. - 7/10




93%