Reviewed - 24th July 2002 by PCL

Ali (2001) - Warner

Director : Michael Mann

Starring : Will Smith, Jamie Foxx, Jon Voight, Mario Van Peebles, Ron Silver, Mykelti Williamson, Jada Pinkett-Smith

Picture 2.35:1 Anamorphic, DD 5.1, Dual-Layer, Keep Case

Running Time : 157 mins

The story:

Forget what you think you know

Muhammad Ali (Will Smith) from 1964 to 1974, told in three braided threads. The boxer: from becoming champion to regaining the championship from George Forman in the "Rumble in the Jungle". Religion and politics: Cassius Clay becomes Cassius X, a Black Muslim, truncates a friendship with Malcolm X (Mario Van Peebles), becomes Muhammed Ali, refuses induction into the US military, and faces a five-year prison sentence while his case goes to the Supreme Court. Family: he marries twice and by 1974 that marriage is strained, defends his white trainer (Ron Silver), has a brother in Bundini Brown (Jamie Foxx)and is good friends with Howard Cosell (Jon Voight). Throughout, Ali keeps his own counsel: in the ring, at the induction center when he won't step forward, and in friendship, love, and victory.

The summary:

You might be forgiven for thinking that you know most things about one of the worlds most iconic men. Muhammed Ali was at the pinnacle of boxing and some would say showbusiness for over a decade and his life was a rollercoaster of ups and downs.

First off, Will Smith is absolutely superb as Clay/Ali. After spending a whole year preparing for the role and purportedly putting on three stone of muscle (courtesy of IMDB - Not the extras, I will get to that later) he is so much like Ali that you almost think it is a documentary at times. He has completely perfected the accent, the manner, the cockiness, even the walk. He IS Ali. Secondly if you are expecting a film that glamourises his life and celebrates his success you may be disappointed. The film pulls no punches (if you will forgive me) and portrays Ali as a stubborn follower of his chosen religion, who is a serial adulterer and a master boxer. It is a warts and all look at his life over a ten year period and captures the mood very well.

Despite Smith's excellent performance though, the film never does him or the great man justice. The fights are well produced and it does cram in a lot of detail, but ultimately you don't feel the passion and the film sometimes drags limply between scenes. It does portray some genuinely high moments but seems to rely too heavily on the "man of the people" image that Ali tried to project throughout his career and does not seem impartial enough about his dealings with Malcolm X, the nation of Islam or his arrest over the draft. For me the film was more of a fact finding exercise than a look at one of my hero's, having been born slightly too late to capture the Ali bug. What the film did was fill in many blanks about his life and career but did not endear me to the man or fill me with inspiration. It did change the way that I look at Will smith as a serious actor though. Really I think this will most probably appeal to the fans (and there are many) who spent years worshipping the legend.

The DVD is a very disappointing edition. The sound and picture are of average to above average quality, but its the extra's that really disappoint. Let me reiterate my earlier comment. This is a film about one of the most iconic men of our generation. A man that was perhaps more photographed, more profiled, more controversial and more famous than anyone in recent history. So how do they mark this ? well they don't. The disc has no extra's at all. What could have been a fascinating and ingenious blend of movie, historical documentaries along with production footage and interviews has been completely wasted. This is perhaps the first time we have given a zero for extras and deservedly so.

 

Extras:

* Theatrical Trailers - The trailers fro Ali and Spiderman along with a teaser for Men In Black 2


Our Verdict...


An unfettered glimpse into the world of Muhammed Ali from becoming World champion to regaining the title seven years later. An excellent portrayal by Will Smith, but the film lacks Ali's charisma and can sometimes be slow and stunted. 5.5/10

Has a good level of quality throughout. Fight scenes sometimes offer a dream like quality and occasionally we are treated to grainy authentic images. 8/10



Dolby 5.1 that sounds just like you imagined it would. Smith IS Ali and his visceral taunts and his thunderous fists are displayed in full surround glory. Very good quality
. 9/10



Laughable. One of the most iconic men of our generation and we get no extras- 0/10




55%